Two types of social value - public and procurement
The end of the Cowboys? A few dollars less….
It’s been 10 years for State of Life in the wild west shoot out of social value.
The Social Value Act of 2010 pumped up social value (unhelpfully). Wellbeing economics was ‘interesting and experimental’ in 2011 but then HMT Treasury was took aim with a definiton of social value and the Wellbeing Guidance for Appraisal in 2021 (on which we are named advisors).
In that time, we have railed against the ‘wild west’ of social value and the pumping out of numbers that don’t pass the sniff test.
Well, it’s good news. As the smoke of the gunfire clears - there is a clear picture emerging of two types of social and economic value.
1. POLICY VALUE - Green Book definition of public and social value
Page 5 of the Green Book: “The social value of a proposal is the value it brings to residents of the United Kingdom. This is not limited simply to financial returns, but all the benefits, costs and risks that affect people’s wellbeing. Social value includes economic prosperity, justice, security, the climate, the environment, people’s health and wellbeing, as well as distributional effects.”
This is the core of what we do at State of Life. We prefer to use the Treasury term ‘Public Value’ as it is about public servants, delivering public value and our job is about asking the public the right questions to get the evidence and accountability we need.
2. PROCUREMENT VALUE - PPN026 and The League of Gentlemen approach
Social Value in procurement has recently been re-defined as:
This the League of Gentlemen approach - local jobs for local people. Alongside it the PPN026 Guidance has started to spell out the need to follow up and make people accountable for delivery of social value.
“taking account of how a supplier will work for our communities to provide good British jobs, skills and opportunities in every postcode”
We are giving it both barrels, pilgrim…
We’re working on both areas but in particular looking at how the two combine to value and buy work better alongside major public expenditure and infrastructure.
The government uses the Green Book to evaluate policies, projects, and programmes to ensure public money is spent effectively. And with our clients, we are building a model of New Work, Better Work and Skilled Work. Our framework starts where the social value procurement guidelines of PPN026 stops - the evaluation that occurs alongside procurement to ensure we meet the policy objectives and get public value for public money spent.
New work - is the job for someone who is previously unemployed or is it simply someone moving from one job to another? If it’s the latter the value of the job is practically zero from a social value perspective.
Better work - is the work safe and satisfying? This has a significant impact on us and our communities.
Skilled work - does the job come with training and skills development? This helps you stay employed, get better jobs and earn more money (productivity).
Coming soon will be pulling the trigger on what we think is the best way to look at this from our work building on Tideway, with Sizewell C and applying the above to what is now over £100bn of public money.
“Stick ‘em up, cowboys….there’s a new Sheriff in town and that town is Royston Vasey.”